Guest Post: Worst Kept Secrets/Best Laid Plans

On Sunday night the All Blacks selectors confirmed what even my Mum could have told you – that league convert Sonny Bill Williams would be taken on the end of year tour, the defacto dress rehearsal for next year’s Rugby World Cup.

I mean, why in God’s name would you bring the guy back from France, pay him what apparently makes him the third highest earning rugby player in the country (after McCaw and Carter), and leave him to languish in the ITM Cup with the RWC less than a year away? Why would you ignore his potential as a brand, with the game increasingly competing for our entertainment dollar against league, and increasingly, soccer? And perhaps most importantly – why would you ignore his awesome, awesome potential as a matchwinning gamebreaker?

Apart from an injury impacted start (and a poor decision concerning a ski trip), SBW has been really quite spectacular forCanterbury. He is phenomenally strong, has an almost unbelievable ability to draw defenders and offload in contact, and perhaps most importantly he has improved with each passing week. He perhaps still struggles a little operating within Union’s defensive patterns, but surely there is no better place or time for him to work on his defense than in the All Black team environment?

One must feel a little for his Cantabs midfield partner Robbie Fruean, whose form has been every bit as commanding as SBW’s, but has not been selected – his number may actually have been up when SBW operated reasonably effectively in the 13 jersey, and with the coaches instead opting to place their faith in the returning, already test-proven Isaia Toeava. In fact, Sonny Bill aside, this must be the most experienced All Blacks squad ever selected, with no fewer than 12 players boasting more than 40 caps apiece.

Which means no place for either of 2010’s backup first fives, Colin Slade or Aaron Cruden, with the poisoned chalice of being Daniel Carter’s backup returned to 2009’s most vilified performer, Stephen Donald. Whilst Donald has turned on three outstanding, matchwinning performances on the trot for Waikato, he is yet to convince at international level – if he can do so on this trip (especially with Carter in doubt for the Bledisloe game in Hong Kong on the way), it is a terrific selection – if he again looks jittery and inept, a golden opportunity to advance the credentials and experience of, say, Slade has been utterly wasted.

Saturday evening’s sickening injury to the versatile, assured Piri Weepu also had to be factored in – without him, the All Blacks are without their most dynamic halfback, an accomplished goalkicker, a leader, and a definite additional option at first five. With his broken leg taking him out of the game for up to six months, the selectors will have ample opportunity to check their halfback stocks, with Alby Mathewson and Andy Ellis being the beneficiaries of Weepu’s misfortune. Conversely, it may be Cowan who ends up feeling the heat if Mathewson and Ellis end up being a better fit for the AB’s high velocity gameplan…

Other noteworthy selections and omissions include Sevens captain Liam Messam getting the nod in place of Victor Vito, who has clearly been given some work-ons after his game in Sydney, where it took Jerome Kaino coming off the bench in his place to sure things up and help effect the victory – if the selectors are looking for a loose forward who plays a little ‘tighter’, however, I’m not entirely sure Messam is their guy. Daniel Braid earns a place as McCaw’s backup on the back of some outstanding form for Auckland since returning from Queensland, and together with 2010’s biggest mover, number eight Kieran Read, they make up a loose forward quintet that strongly suggests McCaw may be spending some time on the blindside.

My other significant concern would be the number of players going on tour on the back of little or no game time – Carter, Mealamu, Hore, Sivivatu, Donald and Toeava are all touring despite coming off some serious injuries. If Mealamu and Hore were unfit for the Hong Kong match, the uncapped Hikawera Elliott would have to start at hooker, with front row ‘jack of all trades’ (fill in the blank) John Afoa backing him up, and similarly, if Carter were not ready for that match, Donald would start with, presumably, someone like Toeava as his cover. Worrying, and again, evidence of what a significant loss Weepu is.

The All Blacks squad (with province and Test caps in brackets) is:

John Afoa                        Auckland (25)
Anthony Boric                 North Harbour (16)
Daniel Braid                    Auckland (4)
Tom Donnelly                 Otago (13)
Hikawera Elliot                Hawkes Bay (0)
Ben Franks                      Tasman (7)
Owen Franks                  Canterbury (17)
Andrew Hore                   Taranaki (47)
Jerome Kaino                 Auckland (33)
Richie McCaw (capt)     Canterbury (89)
Keven Mealamu             Auckland (80)
Liam Messam                 Waikato (5)
Kieran Read                    Canterbury (25)
Brad Thorn                      Canterbury (46)
Samuel Whitelock          Canterbury (8)
Tony Woodcock              North Harbour (69)
Andy Ellis                      Canterbury (14)
Daniel Carter                Canterbury (74)
Jimmy Cowan              Southland (41)
Stephen Donald           Waikato (19)
Hosea Gear                   Wellington (2)
Cory Jane                      Wellington (20)
Alby Mathewson          Wellington (1)
Mils Muliaina                Waikato (89)
Maa Nonu                    Wellington (52)
Josevata Rokocoko     Auckland (66)
Sitiveni Sivivatu           Waikato (43)
Conrad Smith               Wellington (41)
Isaia Toeava                  Auckland (26)
Sonny Bill Williams     Canterbury *
* new All Black

– Jeremy Taylor


Leave a comment

Filed under Rugby

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s